back to home

presidents and vice presidents

sponsors

members

forthcoming debates

previous debates

tickets

 
Debates 1991-2000

20th March 2000   Political parties should be allowed to advertise on TV and radio as well as in other media
 
  Sponsor: Radio Advertising Bureau

In the chair: Lord Gordon of Strathblane
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Derek Wyatt MP
Member of Parliament
for Sittingbourne & Sheppey

Simon Marquis
Managing Director
Zenith

Peter Bottomley MP
Member of Parliament
for Worthing West

Mike Moran
Commercial Director
Toyota

 

 
23rd November 1998   Modern politics are more concerned with image than reality (Carried)
 
  Sponsor: Publicity Club of London

In the chair: Dennis Lipton (standing in for Cheryl Gillan MP)
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Cheryl Gillan MP
(standing in for the Rt Hon Ann
Widdecombe MP)

Mike McCormack
(standing in for Boris Johnson
Assistant Editor, Daily Telegraph)

Robin Corbett MP
Member of Parliament
for Birmingham Erdington

Keith McDowall
Former Deputy General at the CBI

 

 
26th October 1998   Sponsor: Market Reserach Society - cancelled
 

 
6th July 1998   The Press has done more for public health than governments (Defeated)
 
  Sponsor: Periodical Publishers Association

In the chair: The Rt Hon Ann Widdecombe MP
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Dr Thomas Stuttaford OBE
Medical journalist & physician

Dr Fleur Fisher
Chairman Teenage Magazine Arbitration Panel

The Rt Hon Stephen Dorrell MP
Former Secretary of State for Health

Sally Keeble MP
Former journalist & author on health

 

 
27th October 1997   Governments should keep their hands off advertising (Carried)
 
  Sponsor: International Advertising Association

In the chair: Roger Haywood (Deputising for Austin Mitchell MP)
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Winston Fletcher
Chairman Bozell UK Group

Peter Fiddick
Media commentator
Editor of Research

Andrew Brown
Director General
The Advertising Association

Martyn Bond
Director
UK office of the European Parliament

 

 
16th June 1997   Advertising shapes society more than politicians (Carried)
 
  Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising

In the chair: Austin Mitchell MP
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Hugh Burkitt
Chairman Court Burkitt & Co Ltd

Roger Holland
Chief Executive JICREG

Peter York
Cultural Commentator Director
SRU

Lord McNally
Vice Chairman
Shandwick Consultants

 

 
26th May 1997   Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising
Postponed - debated in October
 

 
24th March 1997   Sponsor: IPA Society
Postponed due to General Election - debated in June
 

 
20th January 1997   Sponsor: Periodical Publisher's Association
Cancelled
 

 
25th November 1996   Sponsor: The Market Research Society
Cancelled
 

 
28th October 1996   Electronic media are achieving more for global democracy than traditional media (Defeated)
 
  Sponsor: Direct Marketing Association

In the chair: Iain Mills MP
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Christopher Millard
Partner
Clifford Chance

Robin Fairlie
Direct Marketing Consultant

Tony Coad
Development Director
The Telegraph

Perri 6
Research Director
Demos

 

 
3rd July 1995   Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising
Cancelled due to speakers feeling that the cross-media ownership based motion was too topical
 

 
22nd May 1995   Advertising can seriously damage your health (Defeated)
 
  Sponsor: International Advertising Association

In the chair: The Lord Colwyn
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Adrian Holmes
Chairman
Lowe Howard-Spink

Jean Lambert
Former Chair
The Green Party

Martin Smith
Deputy Chairman
Bartle Bogle Hegarty

Andrew Harrison
Editor
Select Magazine

 

 
20th March 1995   Government is the major obstacle to development of the information society (Carried)
 
  Sponsor: Periodical Publisher's Association

In the chair: Lord McGregor
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  David Arculus
Director
EMAP plc

Roger Gale MP
Member of Parliament
for North Thanet

Professor Hugh Stephenson
Head of Journalism Studies
City University

Carole Tongue MEP
Member of European Parliament
for London East

 

 
23rd January 1995   Market research serves the public better than consumer legislation (Defeated)
 
  Sponsor: The Market Research Society

In the chair: Lord Ezra
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Michael Warren
Director General
Market Research Society

John Wizgell
Market Research Consultant

Sheila McKechnie
Director
Consumer Association

Geoff Hoon MP
Member of Parliament
for Ashfield

 

 
21st November 1994   Most advertising will be individually targeted and personalised by the year 2000 (Defeated)
 
  Sponsor: Direct Marketing Association

In the chair: Graham Allen MP
 

  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Michael Heron
Chairman
The Post Office

Victor Ross
Former Chairman
Reader's Digest Association

Winston Fletcher
Chairman
DFSD Bozell

Chris Powell
Chief Executive
BMP DDP Needham

 

 
24th January 1994   Sponsorship benefits consumers more than advertising
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  John Billett
Chief Executive
The Billett Consultancy

Shaun Powell
Head of Marketing
Barclaycard

Kenneth Miles
Director General
Incorporated Society of British Advertisers

M T Rainey
Managing Partner
Rainey Kelly Campbell Roalfe

 

 
22nd November 1993   Society gets the media it deserves
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Austin Mitchell MP
Member of Parliament
for Great Grimsby

Brian MacArthur
Executive Editor (Features)
The Times

Michael Norton
Director
The Directory of Social Change

Judith Church
Senior Official MSF
Member of Labour's NEC

 

 
19th October 1992   Broadcast media make literacy irrelevant (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Brian Roberts
Managing Director
Taylor Nelson Group Limited (AGB)

Harold Lind
Media Consultant

David Tector
Assistant Managing Director
Grimsby Evening Telegraph

Sue Phipps
PR Consultant

 

 
16th March 1992   Marketing not Money will be the salvation of Eastern Europe (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Dr Norman Wooding CBE
Chairman
East European Trade Council

John Mitchell
Chairman
ICI East Europe

Ralph Land OBE
Director East European Affairs
Rolls Royce plc

Lyall Davidson
Chairman
CIM Central London Branch

 

 
27th January 1992   Proportional representation will benefit industry through greater stability (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Robin Squire
Member of Parliament
For Hornchurch

Winston Fletcher
Chairman
Delaney, Fletcher, Delaney Bozell

Douglas Hoyle
Member of Parliament
for Warrington North

Chris Powell
Chief Executive
BMP DDP Needham

 

 
18th November 1991   Effective public relations distorts the democratic process (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Sarah Baxter
Polititical Editor
New Statesman & Society

Fran Bennett
Director
Child Poverty Action Group

Jerry Hayes
Member of Parliament
for Harrow

Roger Haywood
President
IPR

 

 
21st October 1991   Manifestos should be based on conviction politics rather than opinion polls (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Derek Hatton
Former Leader
Liverpool City Council

Brian Gosschalk
Director of Political Research
MORI

John Clemens
Chairman
Continental Research

Harvey Thomas
Former Director of Presentations
The Conservative Party

 

Back to top | Debates 1975-1980 | Debates 1981-1990 | Debates 2001-2010