|
20th March 2000
|
Political parties should be allowed to advertise on TV and radio as well as in other media
|
| |
Sponsor: Radio Advertising Bureau
In the chair: Lord Gordon of Strathblane
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Derek Wyatt MP
Member of Parliament
for Sittingbourne & Sheppey
Simon Marquis
Managing Director
Zenith
|
Peter Bottomley MP
Member of Parliament
for Worthing West
Mike Moran
Commercial Director
Toyota
|
|
|
23rd November 1998
|
Modern politics are more concerned with image than reality (Carried)
|
| |
Sponsor: Publicity Club of London
In the chair: Dennis Lipton (standing in for Cheryl Gillan MP)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Cheryl Gillan MP
(standing in for the Rt Hon Ann
Widdecombe MP)
Mike McCormack
(standing in for Boris Johnson
Assistant Editor, Daily Telegraph)
|
Robin Corbett MP
Member of Parliament
for Birmingham Erdington
Keith McDowall
Former Deputy General at the CBI
|
|
|
26th October 1998
|
Sponsor: Market Reserach Society - cancelled
|
|
|
6th July 1998
|
The Press has done more for public health than governments (Defeated)
|
| |
Sponsor: Periodical Publishers Association
In the chair: The Rt Hon Ann Widdecombe MP
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Dr Thomas Stuttaford OBE
Medical journalist & physician
Dr Fleur Fisher
Chairman Teenage Magazine Arbitration Panel
|
The Rt Hon Stephen Dorrell MP
Former Secretary of State for Health
Sally Keeble MP
Former journalist & author on health
|
|
|
27th October 1997
|
Governments should keep their hands off advertising (Carried)
|
| |
Sponsor: International Advertising Association
In the chair: Roger Haywood (Deputising for Austin Mitchell MP)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Winston Fletcher
Chairman Bozell UK Group
Peter Fiddick
Media commentator
Editor of Research
|
Andrew Brown
Director General
The Advertising Association
Martyn Bond
Director
UK office of the European Parliament
|
|
|
16th June 1997
|
Advertising shapes society more than politicians (Carried)
|
| |
Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising
In the chair: Austin Mitchell MP
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Hugh Burkitt
Chairman Court Burkitt & Co Ltd
Roger Holland
Chief Executive JICREG
|
Peter York
Cultural Commentator Director
SRU
Lord McNally
Vice Chairman
Shandwick Consultants
|
|
|
26th May 1997
|
Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising
Postponed - debated in October
|
|
|
24th March 1997
|
Sponsor: IPA Society
Postponed due to General Election - debated in June
|
|
|
20th January 1997
|
Sponsor: Periodical Publisher's Association
Cancelled
|
|
|
25th November 1996
|
Sponsor: The Market Research Society
Cancelled
|
|
|
28th October 1996
|
Electronic media are achieving more for global democracy than traditional media (Defeated)
|
| |
Sponsor: Direct Marketing Association
In the chair: Iain Mills MP
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Christopher Millard
Partner
Clifford Chance
Robin Fairlie
Direct Marketing Consultant
|
Tony Coad
Development Director
The Telegraph
Perri 6
Research Director
Demos
|
|
|
3rd July 1995
|
Sponsor: Institute of Practitioners in Advertising
Cancelled due to speakers feeling that the cross-media ownership based motion was too topical
|
|
|
22nd May 1995
|
Advertising can seriously damage your health (Defeated)
|
| |
Sponsor: International Advertising Association
In the chair: The Lord Colwyn
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Adrian Holmes
Chairman
Lowe Howard-Spink
Jean Lambert
Former Chair
The Green Party
|
Martin Smith
Deputy Chairman
Bartle Bogle Hegarty
Andrew Harrison
Editor
Select Magazine
|
|
|
20th March 1995
|
Government is the major obstacle to development of the information society (Carried)
|
| |
Sponsor: Periodical Publisher's Association
In the chair: Lord McGregor
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
David Arculus
Director
EMAP plc
Roger Gale MP
Member of Parliament
for North Thanet
|
Professor Hugh Stephenson
Head of Journalism Studies
City University
Carole Tongue MEP
Member of European Parliament
for London East
|
|
|
23rd January 1995
|
Market research serves the public better than consumer legislation (Defeated)
|
| |
Sponsor: The Market Research Society
In the chair: Lord Ezra
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Michael Warren
Director General
Market Research Society
John Wizgell
Market Research Consultant
|
Sheila McKechnie
Director
Consumer Association
Geoff Hoon MP
Member of Parliament
for Ashfield
|
|
|
21st November 1994
|
Most advertising will be individually targeted and personalised by the year 2000 (Defeated)
|
| |
Sponsor: Direct Marketing Association
In the chair: Graham Allen MP
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Michael Heron
Chairman
The Post Office
Victor Ross
Former Chairman
Reader's Digest Association
|
Winston Fletcher
Chairman
DFSD Bozell
Chris Powell
Chief Executive
BMP DDP Needham
|
|
|
24th January 1994
|
Sponsorship benefits consumers more than advertising
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
John Billett
Chief Executive
The Billett Consultancy
Shaun Powell
Head of Marketing
Barclaycard
|
Kenneth Miles
Director General
Incorporated Society of British Advertisers
M T Rainey
Managing Partner
Rainey Kelly Campbell Roalfe
|
|
|
22nd November 1993
|
Society gets the media it deserves
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Austin Mitchell MP
Member of Parliament
for Great Grimsby
Brian MacArthur
Executive Editor (Features)
The Times
|
Michael Norton
Director
The Directory of Social Change
Judith Church
Senior Official MSF
Member of Labour's NEC
|
|
|
19th October 1992
|
Broadcast media make literacy irrelevant (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Brian Roberts
Managing Director
Taylor Nelson Group Limited (AGB)
Harold Lind
Media Consultant
|
David Tector
Assistant Managing Director
Grimsby Evening Telegraph
Sue Phipps
PR Consultant
|
|
|
16th March 1992
|
Marketing not Money will be the salvation of Eastern Europe (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Dr Norman Wooding CBE
Chairman
East European Trade Council
John Mitchell
Chairman
ICI East Europe
|
Ralph Land OBE
Director East European Affairs
Rolls Royce plc
Lyall Davidson
Chairman
CIM Central London Branch
|
|
|
27th January 1992
|
Proportional representation will benefit industry through greater stability (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Robin Squire
Member of Parliament
For Hornchurch
Winston Fletcher
Chairman
Delaney, Fletcher, Delaney Bozell
|
Douglas Hoyle
Member of Parliament
for Warrington North
Chris Powell
Chief Executive
BMP DDP Needham
|
|
|
18th November 1991
|
Effective public relations distorts the democratic process (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Sarah Baxter
Polititical Editor
New Statesman & Society
Fran Bennett
Director
Child Poverty Action Group
|
Jerry Hayes
Member of Parliament
for Harrow
Roger Haywood
President
IPR
|
|
|
21st October 1991
|
Manifestos should be based on conviction politics rather than opinion polls (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Derek Hatton
Former Leader
Liverpool City Council
Brian Gosschalk
Director of Political Research
MORI
|
John Clemens
Chairman
Continental Research
Harvey Thomas
Former Director of Presentations
The Conservative Party
|