|
21st May 1990
|
The portrayal of women in advertisements is out of step with changing social attitudes (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Emma Nicholson
Member of Parliament
Devon West & Torridge
Joanne Foster
Chair
Equal Opportunities Commission
|
A E Pitcher
Past President
Ogilvy & Mather
Marilyn Baxter
Director of Planning
Saatchi & Saatchi
|
|
|
29th January 1990
|
The fairest way of allocating ITV franchises is to the highest bidder (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Graham Riddick
Member of Parliament
for Colne Valley
Professor Martin Cave
Brunell University
|
Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
Great Grimsby
Julian Critchley
Member of Parliament
for Aldershot
|
|
|
27th November 1989
|
This house believes that Market Research expresses public opinion better than the ballot box (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
for Great Grimsby
John Samuels
Former Chairman
MRS
|
Bill Blyth
Former Chairman
MRS
Rt Hon John Biffen
Member of Parliament
for Shropshire North
|
|
|
23rd October 1989
|
Political lobbying is unneccessary in a true democracy (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Tony Banks
Member of Parliament
for Newham NW
Baroness Eward-Biggs
Opposition Whip
House of Lords
|
Adam Raphael
Executive Editor
The Observer
Douglas Smith
President Elect
IPR
|
|
|
17th July 1989
|
Advertising and marketing do more for the quality of life today than religion (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Peter Marsh
Former Chairman
ABM
Joanne Foster
Chair
Equal Opportunities Commission
|
A E Pitcher
Past President
Ogilvy & Mather
Marilyn Baxter
Director of Planning
Saatchi & Saatchi
|
|
|
11th July 1988
|
Global branding is an outmoded concept (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Hywel Jones
Chairman
Hywel Jones Associates
A E Pitcher
Chairman
Robert Jenkins Advertising
|
James Espey
Deputy Managing Director
United Distillers Group
Alan Watson
Chairman
City & Corporation Counsel Ltd
|
|
|
16th May 1988
|
Marketing orientated Chief Executives are more valuable to a company than a Marketing Director (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Jim O'Brien
Joint Managing Director
British Railways Board
Professor Kenneth Simmonds
Professor of Marketing
London Business School
|
Mike Wilson
Managing Director
Marketing Improvements Ltd
Professor Malcolm McDonald
Director - Marketing Planning Center
Cranfield School of Management
|
|
|
28th March 1988
|
Campaigning encourages people to buy more British goods, subject to normal commercial criteria, is essential to British prosperity (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Sir Basil Feldman
Chairman
Better Made in Britain Campaign
Simon Preston
Director
Think British Campaign
|
Roger Haywood
Managing Director
Roger Haywood & Associates
Michael Fallon
Member of Parliament
for Darlington
|
|
|
25th January 1988
|
Banning charities from advertising their aims and objectives on television denies benefit tothe needy (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Michael Brophy
Director
Charities Aid Foundation
Timothy Yeo
Member of Parliament
for Suffolk South
|
Joe Simpson
Assistant Director
Community Service Volunteers
Moyra Tourlmaine
Media Project Officer
Volunteer Centre
|
|
|
30th November 1987
|
The integrity of the British Media has declined (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Michael Shea CVO
Head of Public Affairs
Hanson Trust plc
Carol Friend
Managing Director
Pielle & Co Limited
|
Baron Deedes of Aldington
Former Editor
The Daily Telegraph
Charles Wintour CBE
Distinguished Journalist
|
|
|
27th October 1986
|
Letter boxes should be twice as large so as to encourage twice as much Direct Mail advertising (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Steve Billcliffe
Publishing & Marketing Manager
The Labour Party
Victor Ross
Director
The Folio Society
|
Douglas Smith
Managing Director
Political Communication
Katherine Whitehorn
Columnist & Associate Editor
The Observer
|
|
|
14th July 1986
|
It is impossible for political parties to market themselves honestly (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Tony Ball
World Sales Chief
BL Cars
Peter Bales
Managing Director
Barbour-Builder Limited
|
William Shelton
Member of Parliament
Graham Lancaster
|
|
|
19th May 1986
|
Britain will become an industrial backwater by the year 2000 (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Hywell Jones
Formally of the
Henley Centre
Roy Sanderson OBE
National Officer
EETPU
|
Sir Geoffrey Chandler CBE
Director
Industry Year 1986
Nigel Adam
Editor
Business
|
|
|
10th March 1986
|
If you want something said, go to a man; if you want something done go to a woman
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Peter Snape
Member of Parliament
West Bromwich East
Patricia Rawlings
Campaign Committee
Peace through NATO
|
Rosalind Gilmore
Director - Personal Banking
Girobank plc
Dickie Arbiter
Court Correspondent
IRN/LBC
|
|
|
27th January 1986
|
This House would not put its daughter into advertising (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Mary Whitehouse CBE
President
National Viewers & Listeners Association
Keith Willoughby
Chief Executive
Eggs Authority
|
Jeremy Bullmore CBE
Chairman
J Walter Thompson
Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
for Grimsby
|
|
|
22nd October 1984
|
A mixture of ignorance and prejudice makes journalists bite the advertising hand which feeds them (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Winston Fletcher
Chairman & Chief Executive
Ted Bates Limited
Robin Wight
Chairman
Right Collins Rutherford Scott plc
|
Jean Rook
Assistant Editor
Daily Editor
Sir Alastair Burnet
Director
Independent Television News
|
|
|
16th July 1984
|
Industry in this country would benefit from a freedom of information act (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Des Wilson
Chairman for the Campaign
for Freedom of Information
Austin Mitchell MP
|
Tim Eggar MP
Roger Hayes
Corporate Communications Director
for PA Consulting Group
|
|
|
21st May 1984
|
Magazines will become as obsolete as the steam locomotive (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Nicholas Staveley
Head of Marketing Services
Merlin - British Telecom
Rodney Harris
Media Director
D'Arcy McManus & Masius
|
Michael Bird
Managing Director
International Thomson Publishing Co Ltd
Jane Reed
Managing Director
Holborn Group IPC Magazines
|
|
|
24th March 1984
|
Advertising and the professions go together like oil and water (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
John Bowran
Secretary General
The Law Society
Dr John Marks
Member
General Medical Council
|
Sir Gordon Borrie
Director General
Fair Traiding
Ann Burdus
Deputy Chairman
AGB Limited
|
|
|
30th January 1984
|
Government's policy on cable television helps neither the economy or public requirements (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
John Birt
Director of Programmes
LWT
James Lee
Chairman
Goldcrest Films and Television
|
Nicholas Mellersh
Chief Executive
United Cable Programme
Donald Wray
Assistant Managing Director
Broadband Services, British Telecom
|
|
|
12th July 1982
|
Political parties fail to communicate effectively with the electorate (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Simon Jenkins
Political Editor
The Economist
Roger Hayes
Director
Burson-Marsteller
|
Rt Hon Lord Ardwick
Formerly political advisor
to the Mirror Group
Harvey Thomas
Public Relations
Conservative Central Office
|
|
|
17th May 1982
|
An increase in television channels will have a damaging effect on print media (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Brian Nicholson
Joint Managing Director
The Observer
Brian Jacobs
Leo Burnett Limited
|
Brian Walden
Presenter
ITV's Weekend World
Harry Henry
Independent Consultant
|
|
|
15th March 1982
|
Advertising is such an important means of communication it should be more rigorously controlled (Defeated)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Joan Mackintosh
National Consumer Council
Brian Murphy
Journalist
|
John Jackson
Code of Advertising Practice
Winston Fletcher
Fletcher Shelton Delaney
|
|
|
15th February 1982
|
The community is better served by local radio than local press (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
James Gordon
Managing Director
Radio Clyde
Douglas Cameron
LBC
|
Donald Anderson
Joint Managing Director
United Newspapers
Ron Hunt
Editor
Northampton Evening Telegraph
|
|
|
16th November 1981
|
British Industry does not know how to communicate (Carried)
|
| |
For the motion:
|
Against the motion:
|
| |
Alan Sapper
General Secretary
Cinemategraph, Television
& Allied Technicians
Ken Gill
Amalgamated Union of Engineering
|
Percy Roberts
Former Chairman
Mirror Group
Henry James
Former Director General
COI
|