back to home

presidents and vice presidents

sponsors

members

forthcoming debates

tickets

 
Debates 1981-1990

21st May 1990   The portrayal of women in advertisements is out of step with changing social attitudes (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Emma Nicholson
Member of Parliament
Devon West & Torridge

Joanne Foster
Chair
Equal Opportunities Commission

A E Pitcher
Past President
Ogilvy & Mather

Marilyn Baxter
Director of Planning
Saatchi & Saatchi

 

 
29th January 1990   The fairest way of allocating ITV franchises is to the highest bidder (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Graham Riddick
Member of Parliament
for Colne Valley

Professor Martin Cave
Brunell University

Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
Great Grimsby

Julian Critchley
Member of Parliament
for Aldershot

 

 
27th November 1989   This house believes that Market Research expresses public opinion better than the ballot box (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
for Great Grimsby

John Samuels
Former Chairman
MRS

Bill Blyth
Former Chairman
MRS

Rt Hon John Biffen
Member of Parliament
for Shropshire North

 

 
23rd October 1989   Political lobbying is unneccessary in a true democracy (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Tony Banks
Member of Parliament
for Newham NW

Baroness Eward-Biggs
Opposition Whip
House of Lords

Adam Raphael
Executive Editor
The Observer

Douglas Smith
President Elect
IPR

 

 
17th July 1989   Advertising and marketing do more for the quality of life today than religion (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Peter Marsh
Former Chairman
ABM

Joanne Foster
Chair
Equal Opportunities Commission

A E Pitcher
Past President
Ogilvy & Mather

Marilyn Baxter
Director of Planning
Saatchi & Saatchi

 

 
11th July 1988   Global branding is an outmoded concept (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Hywel Jones
Chairman
Hywel Jones Associates

A E Pitcher
Chairman
Robert Jenkins Advertising

James Espey
Deputy Managing Director
United Distillers Group

Alan Watson
Chairman
City & Corporation Counsel Ltd

 

 
16th May 1988   Marketing orientated Chief Executives are more valuable to a company than a Marketing Director (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Jim O'Brien
Joint Managing Director
British Railways Board

Professor Kenneth Simmonds
Professor of Marketing
London Business School

Mike Wilson
Managing Director
Marketing Improvements Ltd

Professor Malcolm McDonald
Director - Marketing Planning Center
Cranfield School of Management

 

 
28th March 1988   Campaigning encourages people to buy more British goods, subject to normal commercial criteria, is essential to British prosperity (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Sir Basil Feldman
Chairman
Better Made in Britain Campaign

Simon Preston
Director
Think British Campaign

Roger Haywood
Managing Director
Roger Haywood & Associates

Michael Fallon
Member of Parliament
for Darlington

 

 
25th January 1988   Banning charities from advertising their aims and objectives on television denies benefit tothe needy (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Michael Brophy
Director
Charities Aid Foundation

Timothy Yeo
Member of Parliament
for Suffolk South

Joe Simpson
Assistant Director
Community Service Volunteers

Moyra Tourlmaine
Media Project Officer
Volunteer Centre

 

 
30th November 1987   The integrity of the British Media has declined (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Michael Shea CVO
Head of Public Affairs
Hanson Trust plc

Carol Friend
Managing Director
Pielle & Co Limited

Baron Deedes of Aldington
Former Editor
The Daily Telegraph

Charles Wintour CBE
Distinguished Journalist

 

 
27th October 1986   Letter boxes should be twice as large so as to encourage twice as much Direct Mail advertising (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Steve Billcliffe
Publishing & Marketing Manager
The Labour Party

Victor Ross
Director
The Folio Society

Douglas Smith
Managing Director
Political Communication

Katherine Whitehorn
Columnist & Associate Editor
The Observer

 

 
14th July 1986   It is impossible for political parties to market themselves honestly (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Tony Ball
World Sales Chief
BL Cars

Peter Bales
Managing Director
Barbour-Builder Limited

William Shelton
Member of Parliament

Graham Lancaster

 

 
19th May 1986   Britain will become an industrial backwater by the year 2000 (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Hywell Jones
Formally of the
Henley Centre

Roy Sanderson OBE
National Officer
EETPU

Sir Geoffrey Chandler CBE
Director
Industry Year 1986

Nigel Adam
Editor
Business

 

 
10th March 1986   If you want something said, go to a man; if you want something done go to a woman
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Peter Snape
Member of Parliament
West Bromwich East

Patricia Rawlings
Campaign Committee
Peace through NATO

Rosalind Gilmore
Director - Personal Banking
Girobank plc

Dickie Arbiter
Court Correspondent
IRN/LBC

 

 
27th January 1986   This House would not put its daughter into advertising (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Mary Whitehouse CBE
President
National Viewers & Listeners Association

Keith Willoughby
Chief Executive
Eggs Authority

Jeremy Bullmore CBE
Chairman
J Walter Thompson

Austin Mitchell
Member of Parliament
for Grimsby

 

 
22nd October 1984   A mixture of ignorance and prejudice makes journalists bite the advertising hand which feeds them (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Winston Fletcher
Chairman & Chief Executive
Ted Bates Limited

Robin Wight
Chairman
Right Collins Rutherford Scott plc

Jean Rook
Assistant Editor
Daily Editor

Sir Alastair Burnet
Director
Independent Television News

 

 
16th July 1984   Industry in this country would benefit from a freedom of information act (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Des Wilson
Chairman for the Campaign
for Freedom of Information

Austin Mitchell MP

Tim Eggar MP

Roger Hayes
Corporate Communications Director
for PA Consulting Group

 

 
21st May 1984   Magazines will become as obsolete as the steam locomotive (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Nicholas Staveley
Head of Marketing Services
Merlin - British Telecom

Rodney Harris
Media Director
D'Arcy McManus & Masius

Michael Bird
Managing Director
International Thomson Publishing Co Ltd

Jane Reed
Managing Director
Holborn Group IPC Magazines

 

 
24th March 1984   Advertising and the professions go together like oil and water (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  John Bowran
Secretary General
The Law Society

Dr John Marks
Member
General Medical Council

Sir Gordon Borrie
Director General
Fair Traiding

Ann Burdus
Deputy Chairman
AGB Limited

 

 
30th January 1984   Government's policy on cable television helps neither the economy or public requirements (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  John Birt
Director of Programmes
LWT

James Lee
Chairman
Goldcrest Films and Television

Nicholas Mellersh
Chief Executive
United Cable Programme

Donald Wray
Assistant Managing Director
Broadband Services, British Telecom

 

 
12th July 1982   Political parties fail to communicate effectively with the electorate (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Simon Jenkins
Political Editor
The Economist

Roger Hayes
Director
Burson-Marsteller

Rt Hon Lord Ardwick
Formerly political advisor
to the Mirror Group

Harvey Thomas
Public Relations
Conservative Central Office

 

 
17th May 1982   An increase in television channels will have a damaging effect on print media (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Brian Nicholson
Joint Managing Director
The Observer

Brian Jacobs
Leo Burnett Limited

Brian Walden
Presenter
ITV's Weekend World

Harry Henry
Independent Consultant

 

 
15th March 1982   Advertising is such an important means of communication it should be more rigorously controlled (Defeated)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Joan Mackintosh
National Consumer Council

Brian Murphy
Journalist

John Jackson
Code of Advertising Practice

Winston Fletcher
Fletcher Shelton Delaney

 

 
15th February 1982   The community is better served by local radio than local press (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  James Gordon
Managing Director
Radio Clyde

Douglas Cameron
LBC

Donald Anderson
Joint Managing Director
United Newspapers

Ron Hunt
Editor
Northampton Evening Telegraph

 

 
16th November 1981   British Industry does not know how to communicate (Carried)
 
  For the motion:
 
Against the motion:
 
  Alan Sapper
General Secretary
Cinemategraph, Television
& Allied Technicians

Ken Gill
Amalgamated Union of Engineering

Percy Roberts
Former Chairman
Mirror Group

Henry James
Former Director General
COI

 

Back to top | Debates 1975-1980 | Debates 1991-2000 | Debates 2001-2010